The “Einstein” Tile: How a Hobbyist Helped Solve a 60-Year Math Mystery

The “Einstein” Tile: How a Hobbyist Helped Solve a 60-Year Math Mystery

One Small Shape, One Extraordinary Breakthrough

In 2023, retired print technician and tiling enthusiast David Smith helped solve a mathematical mystery nearly 60 years in the making. His discovery, a 13-sided shape nicknamed “the hat,” can cover an infinite flat surface without gaps or overlaps—but can never form a periodically repeating tiling.

Imagine an endless floor made from copies of one tile. The pieces fit perfectly, yet no matter how far you travel, the entire arrangement never settles into a repeating wallpaper pattern. That is the remarkable achievement behind the “einstein” tile.

The story combines hands-on curiosity, computer exploration, and rigorous mathematical teamwork. Its central question is wonderfully approachable: Can one shape force a pattern never to repeat?

What Is an “Einstein” Tile?

Despite the name, this puzzle has nothing to do with Albert Einstein or relativity. “Einstein” is a pun on the German words ein Stein, meaning “one stone.” Mathematicians also call the sought-after shape an aperiodic monotile: one tile shape that can cover the plane, but only nonperiodically.

To understand the challenge, picture a floor covered in identical squares. Slide its infinite grid exactly one square-width sideways, and every tile boundary lines up again. That sliding symmetry makes the tiling periodic.

An aperiodic monotile rules out every such nonzero sliding symmetry. Crucially, it must do more than allow an unusual arrangement: no complete tiling made from it can be periodic.

That distinction separates an interesting design from a mathematical breakthrough. Choosing not to repeat is one thing. Discovering a shape that makes periodic repetition impossible is another.

When examining a tiling, ask whether sliding the entire pattern could make every tile boundary line up again—not merely whether two small patches look alike.

Why the Mystery Lasted Nearly 60 Years

The story stretches back to the 1960s, when mathematician Robert Berger constructed an aperiodic set of 20,426 Wang tiles—squares with colored edges that must match neighboring edges. His work showed that tile sets could permit tilings while forbidding periodic ones.

The next challenge was irresistible: how few different tiles could do the job?

Researchers steadily reduced the number. In the 1970s, Roger Penrose developed famous aperiodic systems using just two tile shapes, together with appropriate matching rules. Getting from thousands of tiles to two was astonishing. Getting from two to one remained elusive.

Earlier single-tile constructions achieved aperiodicity under different conditions. For example, the Taylor–Socolar construction used additional matching rules; expressing those restrictions geometrically required compromises such as a disconnected tile or a three-dimensional construction. The remaining challenge was a single, ordinary flat piece whose outline alone did the work.

The hat answered that challenge without colored-edge instructions or extra rules about which neighbors were allowed. The pieces simply had to fit without gaps or overlapping interiors.

Meet David Smith, the Hobbyist Behind the Hat

David Smith was not approaching the problem as a university researcher. A retired print technician from Yorkshire, England, he was a longtime tiling enthusiast who enjoyed exploring shapes. In late 2022, he identified the promising 13-sided outline that became known as the hat.

Working with paper cutouts could take the investigation only so far. Smith contacted Craig S. Kaplan, a computer scientist at the University of Waterloo, to ask whether his software could help investigate the shape. The eventual collaboration also included software developer Joseph Samuel Myers and mathematician Chaim Goodman-Strauss. The University of Waterloo’s account of the discovery describes how that partnership developed.

This was not a story of intuition replacing expertise. It was a story of different strengths coming together: noticing a promising shape, exploring what it could do, and establishing why it must behave that way.

There is an encouraging lesson here for puzzle lovers. Making an important observation and proving its full significance are different achievements—and collaboration can connect them.

What Makes the Hat So Special?

The hat is an irregular, concave polygon with 13 sides. It can be assembled from eight kite-shaped pieces, making it a polykite. Those smaller kites explain its construction; the finished hat itself is the single tile used in the tiling.

Its outline does not announce its extraordinary property. It looks more like a slightly awkward craft-project piece than the answer to a decades-old problem.

Yet the researchers proved that its geometry forces aperiodicity. They also found that the hat belongs to a continuous family containing infinitely many aperiodic shapes, rather than being one isolated mathematical curiosity.

Importantly, “nonrepeating” does not mean that every neighborhood of tiles is unique. Small arrangements can recur. What cannot recur is the entire infinite tiling through a fixed slide. The pattern has structure without periodicity.

Separate “I found the same little cluster twice” from “the whole design repeats.” A repeated detail does not establish a repeating tiling.

How Do You Prove Something About an Infinite Floor?

No one can lay down infinitely many physical tiles. Even an enormous computer-generated patch leaves the same question: what happens beyond its edge?

The hat investigation therefore needed to establish two things:

  1. Existence: copies of the shape really can cover the entire plane.
  2. Forced aperiodicity: no complete tiling made from them can repeat periodically.

The researchers’ approach included grouping hats into larger clusters called metatiles, then using substitution rules to construct patterns at successively larger scales. Their paper supplied two proofs of aperiodicity, including a computer-assisted analysis showing that hat tilings must have a hierarchical structure.

Think of individual tiles as letters, clusters as words, and larger clusters as sentences. That analogy is only a guide, but it captures the key idea: understanding how small pieces must organize can reveal the structure of an unlimited whole.

Computer assistance was not simply a matter of generating a large picture and declaring victory. One proof systematically checked possible local arrangements; the authors also released verification code. Their hat research and exploration page provides access to the work and interactive tools.

For another accessible example of reasoning beyond trial and error, explore Puzzles Arcade’s mutilated chessboard puzzle. Its argument is much simpler, but it likewise replaces endless attempts with a rule covering every possible arrangement.

The Mirror-Image Twist—and the Spectre

The hat came with an important qualification: every complete hat tiling requires both ordinary hats and reflected, or flipped-over, hats. These count as copies of one shape when reflection is allowed, but they raise a natural follow-up question: could an aperiodic monotile work without needing mirror images?

In May 2023, the same team presented a solution through a family of related shapes called Spectres. Their modified edges enforce aperiodic tilings using translations and rotations, without requiring reflected copies.

The result is stronger than an instruction saying “do not flip the pieces.” Even when reflections are permitted, a complete Spectre tiling uses only one handedness. The team’s Spectre explanation and resources show how this refinement works.

The distinction matters: the hat solved the original geometric monotile problem with reflections allowed; the Spectre resolved the additional handedness challenge.

Try Thinking Like a Tiling Detective

You do not need advanced mathematics to explore the discovery. The researchers’ hat page includes browser-based tools and links for experimenting with virtual tiles.

Try this approach:

  • Start with a small patch and examine its boundary.
  • Notice which gaps admit only a few possible placements.
  • Look for recurring clusters rather than treating every piece separately.
  • Keep track of flipped hats.
  • Distinguish what your experiment suggests from what it proves.

If a growing patch gets stuck, reconsider an earlier placement. One failed arrangement does not show that the shape cannot tile.

For a different hands-on geometry challenge, Puzzles Arcade’s Stomachion puzzle article explores how rearranging a small collection of pieces can open up surprisingly deep questions.

An Amazing Feat Built from Curiosity

The einstein story is memorable because its starting point is so tangible: a shape you can trace, cut out, rotate, and move around.

Its deeper achievement lies in the journey from “this looks promising” to “this must be true.” Smith’s observation mattered. So did the software, the proofs, and the collaborators who helped establish the result.

For puzzle enthusiasts, that is an inspiring combination. Play invites us to notice possibilities. Mathematics asks us to explain them. Occasionally, one small piece brings the two together—and changes what we know is possible.

Share: